The Washington Times
  • Subscribe
  • Times News Services
  • RSS
  • Mobile Headlines
  • e-edition
  • E-MAIL ALERTS
  • REGISTER
  • LOG IN
  • E-MAIL ALERTS
  • WELCOME
  • Your Profile
  • Log Out
  • Front Page Image
  • Classifieds
  • Autos
  • Real Estate
  • Jobs
  • Special Sections
  • Customer Service
  • Home
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Sports
    • NFL
    • NBA/WNBA
    • MLB
    • NHL
    • Tennis
    • Golf
    • Motorsports
    • Soccer
    • NCAA
    • Olympics
    • Outdoors
    • Other
  • Culture
    • Home & Living
    • Family & Kids
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Health
    • Washington Visitors
    • Books
    • Military History
    • Life
    • Auto
    • TV Listings
    • Movie Listings
    • Death Notices
    • Entertainment
  • Themes
  • Communities
  • Shopping
    • Stores
    • Coupons
    • Daily Double
    • Promotion
    • How It Works
  • Videos
    • Two Guys
    • Birnbaum on Washington
    • Liz Glover
    • Amanda Carpenter
    • Morning Briefing
    • Documentaries
    • Joe Giganti
    • Video Game Minute
  • Podcasts
    • About Headlines
    • Audio and Radio
    • America's Morning News
  • Sports

    Redskins can't finish off Eagles

  • Sports

    Woods cancels another meeting with police

  • Business

    Rock 'n' roll is shaking up holiday sales

  • Politics

    Senators want party crashers punished

  • Politics

    Lawmakers wary of Afghan war plans

  • National

    Fed's withdrawal from housing threatens growth

  • World

    Iran vows 10 new uranium plants

Sunday, March 14, 2004

Fast food and fat lawsuits

Rate this story

Average 0.00
after 0 votes
Login or register to rate this story

  • Font Size -+
  • Print
  • Email
  • Comment
  • Tweet this!
  • Share
  • Article
  • Comments ()
  • Click-2-Listen
  • Videos

More Stories

  • Banks in Dubai receive backing
  • Racial turnout key in Atlanta runoff
  • Senators want party crashers punished
  • Study: Early autism treatment pays off

By

For the last year and a half, George Washington University law professor John Banzhaf, who treats the epithet "legal terrorist" as a compliment, has been bragging that fast food restaurants and other purveyors of fattening comestibles are running scared because of the obesity litigation he champions. McDonald's et al. ought to be worried, he said, because already there have been "five successful fat lawsuits."

But now that Congress is considering a ban on lawsuits blaming food manufacturers or sellers for making people fat, Mr. Banzhaf is eager to contradict himself. In a press release issued the day before the House approved the Personal Responsibility in Food Consumption Act by a 2-to-1 margin, he said the bill "is surely premature, because there has been only one obesity lawsuit, and it was dismissed by a federal judge."

Before Congress passes legislation like this, Mr. Banzhaf said, "there should be a real history of abuse which must be corrected, not orchestrated panic based upon one failed lawsuit and some quoted-out-of-context rhetoric." Having orchestrated the panic and provided the rhetoric, he knows whereof he speaks.

Contrary to the impression Mr. Banzhaf left, none of the five "victories" he kept citing involved a plaintiff who blamed a company for his obesity. The biggest case, cooked up by some of Mr. Banzhaf's law students at GW, faulted McDonald's for advertising that its French fries were cooked in vegetable oil while failing to mention they were precooked in beef fat, an omission that understandably upset Hindus and vegetarians. The case, which led to a $10 million settlement in 2002, was a "fat lawsuit" only in the sense it involved cooking fat.

Attempts to hold restaurants responsible for their customers' waistlines have been far less successful -- as Mr. Banzhaf now emphasizes, lest the Senate follow the House's lead and put an early end to the litigious speculation that has brought him the publicity he craves.

The first such case, filed by New York City lawyer Samuel Hirsch, for whom Mr. Banzhaf has been an "informal adviser," met such widespread derision it essentially was laughed out of court.

The plaintiff, you may recall, was a 56-year-old maintenance worker named Caesar Barber, who was 5 feet, 10 inches tall and weighed 272 pounds. The main problem with Mr. Barber, who continued a diet consisting largely of burgers and fries despite a heart attack and warnings from his doctor, was that his stupidity was literally unbelievable.

"They said, '100 percent beef.' I thought that meant it was good for you," Mr. Barber claimed after filing the lawsuit in July 2002. "Those people in the advertisements don't really tell you what's in the food. It's all fat, fat and more fat. Now I'm obese."

Mr. Hirsch eventually dumped Mr. Barber in favor of two hefty New York teenagers who claimed to have eaten at McDonald's on most days of the week for years. That lawsuit, which Mr. Hirsch intended as a class action, was dismissed twice, the second time with prejudice, for failing to adequately state a claim.

12Next »

Post a comment

There are comments on this article, submit your opinion!

Commenting is disabled for this entry.
If you feel there is still something worth mentioning about this entry please contact the author or the site admin.

Ask a Question

You Report

Do you have another point of view, photos, audio, video or more information about a story?

Top Stories

Most Read

  1. EDITORIAL: Hiding evidence of global cooling
  2. EDITORIAL: The global-cooling cover-up
  3. Robotic hamster holiday craze
  4. PRUDEN: Trouble afoot for high priests
  5. Wife aids Woods after SUV crash
More Top Stories »
  1. Fenty's approval in D.C. divided by race
  2. Climate 'czar' says hacked e-mails don't change anything
  3. Grayson's Senate filibuster petition faulted
  4. In tobacco-loving Virginia, bars give up the habit
  5. Residency at issue in Va. Senate race

Most Shared

  1. Multiculturalism on trial
  2. EDITORIAL: Hiding evidence of global cooling
  3. EDITORIAL: Barbie converts to Islam
  4. Indiana's Daniels offers austerity as a virtue
  5. EDITORIAL: The global-cooling cover-up
More Top Stories »
  1. PRUDEN: Trouble afoot for high priests
  2. EDITORIAL: Death tax redux
  3. Quiet GOP tactic stalls top Obama appointments
  4. Defensive medicine costs
  5. The United Socialist States of America

Most Commented

  1. Palin is appealing but pedestrian
  2. Quiet GOP tactic stalls top Obama appointments
  3. Report: Bin Laden was 'within our grasp'
  4. EDITORIAL: Barbie converts to Islam
  5. Grayson's Senate filibuster petition faulted
More Top Stories »
  1. EDITORIAL: The global-cooling cover-up
  2. Senate divided as health debate begins
  3. Woods cancels meeting with police for 3rd time
  4. Obama faces hard sell on Afghan decision
  5. Multiculturalism on trial

Listen to Washington Times Radio

  • America's Morning News

    with John McCaslin and Melanie Morgan

Blogs & Columns

  • Hot Button Blog

    RNC: Breast cancer recommendations may lead to 'rationing'

  • Belief Blog

    Evangelicals OK civil disobedience

  • Out of Context

    Foods that might kill libido

  • On the Fly

    United lifts some 'award' blocking

  • Technology

    Facebook wins round against phishing spammer

  • Redskins 360

    Haynesworth out

  • SNOBlog

    Beyond 'Woody'

Videos

Advertising Links
TWT Store
  • e-edition
  • Print Edition
  • Weekly Washington Times
TWT Affiliates
  • Middle East Times
  • Golf
  • UPI
  • Arbor Ballroom
  • Washington Times Global
  • About TWT
  • Press Room
  • F.A.Q.
  • Work for TWT
  • Advertise
  • Sponsors
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Map

All site contents © Copyright 2009 The Washington Times, LLC.