BROWNSVILLE, Texas — Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton yesterday targeted her Democratic rival with a new ad that asks voters who they would trust to protect their families when a national security crisis strikes.
Sen. Barack Obama called it a scare tactic and rapidly cut a response ad to begin airing today.
In the Clinton spot airing in Texas, sleeping children are shown as the narrator says: “It’s 3 a.m. and your children are safe and asleep, but there’s a phone in the White House and it’s ringing. Something’s happening in the world.
“Your vote will decide who answers that call,” it continues. “Whether it’s someone who already knows the world’s leaders, knows the military someone tested and ready to lead in a dangerous world.”
The ad does not mention Mr. Obama, but the implication is clear — the former first lady has more experience on national security. She evokes the September 11 terrorist attacks on the stump and her role as a U.S. senator from the ground-zero state of New York.
The Obama campaign dismissed the effort as “not going to be effective,” and Mr. Obama said it was a tactic to “play upon people’s fears to scare up votes.”
Obama advisers compared the Clinton ad to what was dubbed the “Red Phone” spot that Walter Mondale ran against Gary Hart in 1984, and political pundits likened it to the “Daisy” ads President Lyndon Johnson ran against Barry Goldwater in 1964.
The Obama campaign said Mrs. Clinton failed her “red phone moment” by voting to authorize the Iraq war in 2002 and noted that ad guru Roy Spence, who created the Mondale spot, was responsible for Mrs. Clinton’s new ad.
The Obama response ad repurposes the Clinton version with text and narration boosting his message.
It uses the “It’s 3 a.m. line,” but adds its own spin: “When that call gets answered, shouldn’t the president be the one — the only one — who had judgment and courage to oppose the Iraq war from the start?’
“Who understood the real threat to America was al Qaeda, in Afghanistan, not Iraq, who led the effort to secure loose nuclear weapons around the globe?” it continues as images of Mr. Obama fill the screen. “In a dangerous world, it’s judgment that matters.”
The national security play came only days before four make-or-break Tuesday contests.
Polls suggest that each candidate holds a strong lead in one state — Mr. Obama in Vermont and Mrs. Clinton in Rhode Island. She holds a lead in Ohio that has drastically eroded, while Mr. Obama has been consistently leading in the latest Texas polls.
In Waco, Texas, Clinton supporter retired Army Gen. Wesley Clark defended the campaign’s ringing-phone TV ad, saying that he had personal experience making those type of emergency middle-of-the-night calls to the White House and that voters needed to think about who they wanted answering such calls.
“I’m not here to try to scare anyone. We’re Democrats,” he said at a rally at the Waco Convention Center, where Mrs. Clinton was surrounded on stage by two dozen retired military leaders who served in conflicts dating back to World War II.
Mrs. Clinton said that national security has been an issue in every presidential race. “Senator Obama says when we talk about national security we are trying to scare people. I don’t think the people of Texas scare that easy,” she said.
Mr. Obama derided the ads at an evening rally in a packed San Antonio amphitheater, drawing boos when saying he wanted to discuss “an ad that Senator Clinton put up today.”
He described it as asking, “Who do you want answering the phone in the White House when it’s 3 a.m. and something has happened in the world?” and many in the 8,000-strong crowd responded, “Obama!”
“Senator Clinton may not be aware, but we already had a ’red-phone’ moment, it was the decision to invade Iraq,” he said. “And Senator Clinton picked up the phone and gave the wrong answer.”
In Houston earlier, Mr. Obama told about 75 veterans the ad raised a legitimate question and the point he’d make is, “What kind of judgment will you exercise when you pick up that phone?”
Mr. Obama won backing from Sen. John D. Rockefeller IV of West Virginia, the chairman of the Senate intelligence committee, who trumpeted the junior senator as strong on the issues that matter most.
“It’s about getting it right on crucial national security questions the first time — and every time,” he said.
Mr. Obama tried to cut into Mrs. Clinton’s support among Hispanic voters, speaking with evangelical Hispanic leaders about faith in South Texas yesterday. He also took a tour of the border and went to a sombrero festival.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.